VAR in the Premier League: Has It Actually Been a Good Thing?

Sunday's Manchester derby reminded English football again why VAR remains one of the most debated additions to the modern game.

Erling Haaland's 60th-minute winner at Old Trafford was initially ruled out for offside on the field, but VAR intervened and awarded the goal. The bigger issue lay one step further back: Manchester City's Enzo Fernandez was in an offside position closer to goal and moved toward the cross without touching it, appearing to influence how Manchester United defender Lisandro Martinez reacted.

Lisandro Martinez Reaction to VAR Decision from ESPN on X

Hours later, Pro Ref, the body that oversees Premier League officiating, admitted the VAR had made "an error of judgement" and should have sent referee Michael Oliver to review the goal on the pitch himself. Pro Ref confirmed it had contacted Manchester United directly to acknowledge the mistake and that a formal review would follow, though the result itself was not expected to change. It was City's only goal in a match they finished with ten men after Phil Foden's early red card, which made the decision even more costly for United.

It is the kind of incident that reopens a question fans, pundits, and bettors have been asking since VAR arrived in the league in 2019: does it actually make the game fairer, or has it just moved the controversy somewhere new?

What was VAR actually built to do?
VAR checks every goal automatically, along with penalty decisions, direct red cards, and cases of mistaken identity. For factual calls, such as whether a player was offside or the ball had gone out of play, VAR simply corrects the record. For subjective calls, like a foul or a handball, VAR is only supposed to intervene when the on-field decision is a clear error, leaving the final call with the referee on the pitch.

That distinction matters, because the Haaland incident sat in an awkward middle ground. Whether Enzo Fernandez's position affected the play was treated as a subjective offside call, which is exactly the kind of situation where VAR is meant to be more cautious about overturning the referee's original read.

The case for VAR
The numbers make a real case that VAR has improved accuracy. Before its introduction, the Premier League's independent panel found that officials got roughly 82 percent of key match incidents correct. Within a season of VAR being introduced, that figure rose to 94 percent. According to the Premier League's own review of the 2024/25 season, once VAR intervenes, the accuracy rate on those decisions now sits at 97 percent, and the total number of VAR errors fell from 31 the season before to 18.

The league has also worked to make the process faster. Average VAR delay dropped from 64 seconds to 39 seconds last season, helped by semi-automated offside technology, which alone saved around 27 seconds per offside check.

On paper, that is a system that catches far more of the game's biggest mistakes than referees managed on their own.

The case against VAR
The numbers only tell part of the story, and the part they leave out is exactly what fans feel every matchday. Independent tracking of the current Premier League season shows VAR reviews now average over four minutes, the longest of any major European league, even as total VAR overturns have actually dropped. At the same time, panel-verified errors are reported to be up significantly on last season, meaning games are being paused for longer with more, not fewer, high-profile mistakes slipping through.

Some of those mistakes have become infamous on their own. Liverpool had a perfectly good Luis Diaz goal ruled out against Tottenham in 2023 after a communication breakdown between the referee and VAR left the goal disallowed even though both officials briefly agreed it should stand. Arsenal saw an Ivan Toney goal wrongly allowed against them the same weekend after the VAR failed to draw the offside lines correctly. Jordan Pickford's reckless collision with Virgil van Dijk in a Merseyside derby went unpunished by VAR because the phase of play was ruled offside first, a decision that still frustrates Liverpool fans years later.

The common thread across these cases is not that VAR lacks good intentions. It is that a system built to remove human error is still run entirely by humans, which means it inherits many of the same weaknesses it was meant to fix, just with more scrutiny and more time added around each one.

The biggest VAR controversies so far
A few incidents have come to define the VAR era in England, for all the wrong reasons.

  • Luis Diaz vs Tottenham, 2023: Widely considered the worst VAR error in Premier League history. Diaz's goal was ruled out for offside despite replays clearly showing he was level with the last defender. A communication breakdown meant the VAR official believed the goal had already been confirmed, but by the time the error was spotted, play had restarted and the goal could not be legally awarded. Liverpool lost the match, and PGMOL issued a rare formal apology.

  • Ivan Toney vs Arsenal, 2023: On the same weekend as the Diaz incident, Brentford's Toney had a goal wrongly allowed to stand after the VAR forgot to draw the offside lines on the review monitor, missing a clear offside in the buildup. The error was significant enough that the VAR official involved stepped down from his role shortly after.

  • Jordan Pickford vs Virgil van Dijk, 2020: In a Merseyside derby, Everton goalkeeper Pickford clattered into Van Dijk while challenging for a corner, causing a season-ending knee injury. No penalty or red card followed, because the phase of play had already been flagged offside, meaning VAR never assessed the challenge on its own merits at all.

  • Man City vs Tottenham, 2023: With the match deep into stoppage time, referee Simon Hooper blew for a foul on Erling Haaland after play had already continued, denying Spurs a clear goal-scoring opportunity from a Jack Grealish breakaway. PGMOL later admitted it was a straightforward officiating mistake.

  • Man Utd vs Man City, 2026: The most recent addition to the list. Haaland's winning goal at Old Trafford was awarded by VAR despite Enzo Fernandez being in an offside position and appearing to influence the defending, even without touching the ball. Pro Ref admitted the error hours after the final whistle.

So do the pros outweigh the cons?
On accuracy alone, the data leans toward yes. Football now gets more of its biggest decisions right than it did in the pre-VAR era, and that is difficult to argue against on principle. But accuracy is not the only thing supporters and bettors experience. The length of delays, the inconsistency between similar incidents, and moments like the derby error chip away at trust in the system, even when the overall numbers are improving.

The honest answer is that VAR has made the Premier League more accurate and less consistent at the same time. Those two things are not contradictory. A tool can raise the overall success rate while still producing individual failures big enough to define a season, a title race, or, in Sunday's case, a derby.

VAR was introduced to settle arguments, not start new ones, but the Manchester derby is proof that it has not fully done either. The technology has measurably improved how many big decisions referees get right. It has not solved the disagreements over which decisions were ever "clear and obvious" in the first place, and as long as humans are the ones interpreting the replays, that tension is not going away anytime soon.

More from the blog . Booking code converter . Every bet code converter, by country . Hot booking codes today . Betting code tools . AI sports predictions